Unlike the other renewable energy sectors, biogas production did not result from concerns over energy but rather from environmental preoccupations (pollution reduction, waste treatment, greenhouse gas emissions control). Anaerobic digestion means the bacterial breakdown of organic materials in the absence of oxygen. This biochemical process produces a gas, called biogas, principally composed of methane and carbon dioxide. The fossil fuel, natural gas, is primarily methane too but usually of a higher quality than biogas and with a mix of other combustible hydrocarbons. Biogas constitutes a sizeable and renewable form of energy, with European production (EU-27) in the region of 12,1 Mtoe in 2012. See below for a time series on production from the EU-25.

EU25 Biogas Production (in ktoe)

Country

2008

2010

 2012

Germany

3,050

4,235

6,416

United Kingdom

1,615

1,757

1,811

Italy

410

507

1,178

Spain

206

277

290

France

254

353

412

Netherlands

225

293

297

Austria

170

154

207

Denmark

93

104

104

Poland

96

114

168

Belgium

85

127

157

Greece

33

49

88

Finland

45

40

57

Czech Republic

 

56

60

Ireland

49

58

55

Sweden

102

111

126

Hungary

21

36

52

Portugal

23

30

56

Luxembourg

9

11

15

Slovenia

14

30

38

Slovakia

10

14

62

Estonia

2

3

2

Malta

0

0

0

Latvia

8

13

51

Lithuania

3

10

11

Cyprus

1

6

11

Romania

1

3

23

Bulgaria

0

2

0

Croatia

5

7

11

 

TOTAL

6,630

8,530

12,090

 

Source: Eurostat

 

 

AD drivers

The European Union has commited itself to an average reduction of GHG emissions of 20% by 2020 and 40% by 2030 relative to 1990. Agriculture is currently projected to obtain a 17% by 2020 reduction in GHG emissions, partly due to decreasing use of fertilizers and increasing productivity. The agricultural sector is responsible for more than 40% of anthropogenic methane emissions and more than 50% of nitrous oxide emissions. The main sources of methane are enteric fermentation and manure management, while nitrous oxide is mainly derived from the turnover of nitrogen in fertilizers, manure and crop residues, and indirectly from the turnover of nitrogen lost to the environment via ammonia volatilization or nitrate leaching. Both methane and nitrous oxide are potent greenhouse gases with global warming potentials (for a 100-year time horizon) that are, respectively, 21 and 310 times greater than that of CO2. Significant reductions in GHG emissions are therefore possible if methane and nitrous oxide emissions can be reduced via improved management practices.

RTEmagicC biogas facility - UK.TIF

Biogas Plant, UK (IEA Task 37)

Anaerobic digestion (AD) provides possibilities to produce renewable energy from organic wastes in decentralized sites, producing a methane rich biogas from manure (human and animal) and crop residues. Apart from supplying renewable energy AD plants have other positive effects including the strengthening of closed loop recycling management systems, reducing emissions from manure storage and producing a valuable organic fertilizer. It can also create new sources of income for farmers. Currently less then one percent of the potential benefits from AD are being used. Reasons for this include the obstacles such as the legislative framework and the lack of economic incentives for potential investors. Countries like Denmark, Germany, Austria and Sweden promote effective mechanisms to produce biogas from organic wastes by political measurements.

AD technology

In the process of anaerobic digestion, as mentioned above, the bacterial breakdown of organic materials in the absence of oxygen produces biogas, and the process occurs in the following four steps:

  •     Hydrolysis: large polymers are broken down by enzymes
  •     Acidogenesis: acidogenetic fermentations are most important, acetate is the main end product. Volatile fatty acids are also produced along with carbon dioxide and hydrogen.
  •     Acetogenesis: Breakdown of volatile acids to acetate and hydrogen.
  •     Methanogenesis: Acetate, hydrogen are converted to methane and carbon dioxide.

 

AD process design is characterized by four key parameters

Source: German Biogas Association

In the fermentation processes mainly two different temperature ranges are distinguished:

  •     mesophilic temperature from 25 to 35 °C
  •     thermophilic temperature from 49 to 60 °C

The majority of the agricultural biogas plants are operated at mesophilic temperatures. Thermophilic temperatures are applied mainly in large-scale centralised biogas plants with co-digestion, where more stringent sanitation requirements are required.

Biogas plant general design

A biogas plant involves more than just a gas tight manure pit or a digestion vessel, it is usually built up of four elements:

  •     The production unit, which includes the anaerobic digester, possibly a holding tank and/or a sanitation unit and the manure removal system.
  •     The gas storage and gas upgrading system
  •     The equipment for gas and manure utilization

 

0c0d5a7ada

Source: German Biogas Association 

The mode of feeding can be continuous or discontinuous. In discontinuous batch systems the fresh substrate is fed together with an inoculum of digested material into a reaction vessel. During one or two days the material is aerated in order to increase the temperature. During the following two or three weeks the substrate is anaerobically degraded, at first with an increasing daily gas production. After having reached a maximum after approximately 10 to 14 days, gas production decreases again to reach a plateau of about half maximum production. To compensate the unsteady gas formation three to four batch digesters are operated parallel but filled at different times. Batch systems till now are not very common for agricultural biogas plants. Another form of discontinuous process design are storage systems. They combine fermenter and holding tank in one tank. The combined fermentation and holding tank is slowly filled with fresh manure depending on the produced amount. The advantage of this system is the low costs. Problems arise from high heat losses and unsteady gas formation rates.

Biogas upgrading

Usually, the produced biogas must be dried and drained for condense water and biological or chemical cleaned for H2S, NH3 and trace elements. Further upgrading steps to increase the CH4 content, membrane separation of CO2 and pressurising the biogas can be taken depending on the utilisation purpose.

Biogas plants energy efficiency

The net energy output in biogas systems using different raw materials varies depending on transportation distance, means of transportation, conversion techniques and needs for handling of raw materials and digested residues. For Swedish conditions, from a life-cycle perspective, it appears that for transportation distances up to 50 km, the energy needed for running the biogas systems typically corresponds to 30-50 % of the energy content in the produced biogas. All raw materials could be transported more than 150 km, some dry wastes up to 700 km, before the energy balance turns negative. The higher the water content in the raw material, the more sensitive the net energy output is to the transportation distance. There is great variability in data on biogas yield from different raw materials, thus estimations about biogas yield strongly affect the net energy output. Despite inherent uncertainties, the overall conclusion is that the net energy input in the studied biogas systems normally significantly exceeds the energy output in the form of produced biogas.

Energy input in various handling and transportation operations for bringing different raw materials to the biogas plant and for transportation of digested residues, and the biogas yield from various biomass resources. Values within parentheses indicate interval found in the literature.

Raw material

Estimated dry matter content
(%)

Energy input

Energy output

Handling of raw material (GJ/dry t)

Transport of raw material (MJ/dry t, km)

Transport of digested residues
(MJ/dry t, km)

Estimated biogas yield (GJ/dry t)

Ley crops

23

1.7

4.8

20

11

(9.5-17)

Sugar beets tops + leaves

19

0.6

5.8

20

11

(8.5-14)

Manure – pig

8

n/a

14

14

7

(5.6-8.5)

Manure – cow

8

n/a

14

14

6.2

(5.6-8.5)

Slaughter waste

17

n/a

11

20

9.4

 

Grease separator sludge

4

n/a

80

20

22

(20-27)

Municipal organic waste

30

0.6

15

20

14

(8.8-19)

 

Conclusion

 

Biogas can contribute substantially to the sustainable energy recovery from agriculture and the organic fraction of wastes. The amount of agricultural and municipal organic wastes currently available for energy production is very large. The EU energy policy provides the basis for a much broader future application of biogas from anaerobic digestion.

Eurobserver biogas barometer

http://www.energies-renouvelables.org/observ-er/stat_baro/observ/baro212biogas.pdf